Best Shopify Shipping Protection Apps: Top Tools for Warranties & Insurance

Offering product protection, such as warranties and shipping insurance, is no longer a luxury - it's a critical component of a successful e-commerce strategy. These services not only build customer trust by giving shoppers peace of mind but also open up a significant new revenue stream for your store. By providing coverage against lost, stolen, or damaged packages and product defects, you enhance the post-purchase experience, reduce support tickets, and protect your bottom line.

A well-chosen Shopify app can automate this entire process, from displaying an offer at checkout to managing claims. Selecting the right tool is essential for seamless integration and maximizing benefits. This guide provides an expert analysis of the top-rated apps available, based on real user ratings, key features, and pricing structures, to help you make an informed decision for your business.

What you’ll find in this guide:

• A summary table for a quick comparison of the best Shopify shipping protection apps.
• Detailed reviews of each app, highlighting their core strengths and pricing.
• A step-by-step guide on how to choose the perfect app for your store's needs.
• Answers to frequently asked questions about warranties and insurance apps.

Top 9 Shopify Shipping Protection Apps

Before diving into the details, here is a summary of the top apps to help you quickly identify potential fits for your store.

1. Captain Shipping Protection

​Captain Shipping Protection is a leading choice for merchants who want to offer a fully customized, in-house shipping protection program. It excels at allowing you to control the pricing and branding while retaining all the revenue generated.

The app's strength lies in its ability to replace third-party providers entirely.

You can:

• Create and manage your own order protection program.
• Display a protection widget at checkout or through app blocks.
• Customize pricing, styles, and language to match your brand.
• Upsell digital products alongside the protection offer.

Rating: 4.9/5-star.

Pricing: Plans start from $11/month for unlimited orders with a free trial available. Higher-tier plan at $49/month.

2. Shipping Protection —Shipcheck

​Shipcheck empowers merchants to create their own shipping protection service and turn it into a profit center. It is designed to help you recover costs from shipping issues while keeping 100% of the insurance revenue.

The app is known for its effective upsell widget and straightforward revenue model.

Key features include:

• A protection widget for both the cart and checkout pages.
• The ability to charge customers based on their cart value.
• Support for multiple languages and currencies for global stores.
• A model where you keep all the insurance fees collected.

Rating: 4.9/5-star.

3. Guide Shipping Insurance

​Guide Shipping Insurance offers a streamlined way to add package protection at checkout. It is designed for merchants who want a simple, effective solution to build customer confidence and handle claims smoothly.

The app focuses on simplicity and seamless integration.

You can expect:

• Instant protection against lost, damaged, or stolen packages.
• A seamless integration directly into your store's checkout flow.
• A claims process that encourages customers to repurchase from your store.

Rating: 4.7/5-star.

4. Insureful: Shipping Protection

​Insureful provides a flexible framework for merchants to offer custom insurance plans. It stands out with its ability to set coverage based on either a percentage or a fixed value of the cart total.

The app is praised for its rule-based system and transparent claims process.

Core functionalities are:

• Custom insurance plans with adjustable min/max cart value thresholds.
• An insurance widget that appears on the cart and checkout pages.
• Automatic addition of coverage to the cart when criteria are met.
• Claims fulfillment via store credit, reorders, or full refunds.

Rating: 4.8/5-star.

5. ShipGuard: Shipping Protection

​ShipGuard is a completely free solution for businesses looking to implement self-funded shipping protection. It provides the essential tools to manage an in-house insurance program without any monthly fees.

The app is an excellent choice for new or budget-conscious stores.

Its features include:

• The ability to set up custom insurance fees at checkout.
• Options to exclude specific products or variants from coverage.
• An efficient system for managing claims directly within Shopify.
• Tracking for digital insurance fulfillments.

Rating: 4.5/5-star.

6. Simply Shipping Protection

​Simply Shipping Protection gives merchants total control over their insurance offerings, from pricing to placement. It is ideal for stores that want to fine-tune every aspect of their protection upsell.

The app is recognized for its exceptional widget customization.

Key features include:

• Control over pricing with fixed or percentage-based rules.
• Customizable widgets for the cart, side cart, checkout, and post-purchase pages.
• Direct claims management with refund, reorder, or store credit options.
• A live analytics dashboard to track revenue and performance.

Rating: 4.7/5-star.

7. ShipPro Shipping Protection

​ShipPro Shipping Protection is designed to be an easy-to-use revenue generator. It allows stores to offer optional shipping protection as a simple add-on, increasing order value with minimal effort.

This app is great for its one-click upsell and theme compatibility.

You can:

• Offer shipping protection as a percentage of the order value.
• Use features like pre-tick options and one-click upsells.
• Scale insurance offers based on cart value.
• Integrate the app smoothly with all major Shopify themes. 

Rating: 4.4/5-star.

Pricing: Free to install with a free trial available. The paid plan is $9.99/month.

8. My Product Registration

My Product Registration shifts the focus from shipping to post-purchase product warranties. It is an essential tool for brands that sell items requiring registration for warranty claims and long-term support.

It is the go-to app for managing the entire product lifecycle after the sale.

Its strengths are:

• A drag-and-drop form builder for product registration forms.
• Comprehensive warranty management and claims processing tools.
• Seamless integration between customer registrations and claims.
• Tools designed to enhance after-sales service and customer relationships.

Rating: 4.9/5-star.

9. SureBright Product Protection

​SureBright allows merchants to offer both extended warranties and shipping insurance, making it a versatile profit-boosting tool. It partners with you to provide coverage, sharing the revenue from every protection plan sold.

The app is ideal for stores wanting to offer comprehensive product protection with minimal effort.

Key features include:

• Customizable extended warranty and shipping insurance plans.
• Coverage available for over 50 product categories.
• Real-time revenue tracking and a simple online claims process.
• 24/7 support for both merchants and customers.

Rating: 5.0/5-star.

How to Pick the Right Warranties and Insurance Shopify Apps for Your Store?

Choosing the right app requires you to evaluate your business goals and customer needs. Here are the key factors to consider:

1. Protection Model: Self-Funded vs. Third-Party

   • Self-funded apps (e.g., Captain, Shipcheck) let you create your own insurance program and keep 100% of the revenue. This is highly profitable if claims are low but requires you to cover the cost of replacements or refunds yourself.
   • Third-party or hybrid apps (e.g., SureBright) partner with an insurer. You typically share the revenue, but the partner handles the financial risk and claims processing.

2. Type of Coverage: Shipping vs. Product

   • If your main concern is packages lost, stolen, or damaged in transit, a shipping insurance app (e.g., Guide, ShipPro) is ideal.
   • If you sell electronics, furniture, or other goods with a longer lifespan, offering extended warranties through an app like SureBright or My Product Registration adds significant value.

3. Pricing Structure and Fees

   • Look beyond the monthly subscription cost. Check for free plans for getting started, and understand if there are any transaction fees or commission splits on the protection plans sold. Apps like ShipGuard and Corso offer compelling free entry points.

4. Customization and Integration

   • Your protection offer should feel like a natural part of your store. The best apps allow you to customize the widget's appearance and text to match your brand. Ensure the app integrates seamlessly with your checkout, cart, and post-purchase pages without slowing down your site.

5. Claims Management

   • A difficult claims process frustrates customers. Evaluate how an app handles claims. Is it easy for a customer to file one? Can you manage it easily from your Shopify dashboard? Look for flexible fulfillment options like refunds, reorders, or store credit.

FAQs about Warranties and Insurance Apps on Shopify

1. What is the difference between "self-funded" shipping protection and third-party insurance?

Self-funded protection means you, the merchant, collect a fee from the customer and are responsible for covering the cost if a claim is made. You keep all the revenue generated. Third-party insurance involves an external company that underwrites the risk; you typically earn a commission on plans sold, and the third party handles the claim and payout.

2. Can I offer both shipping insurance and extended product warranties?

Yes. Some apps, like SureBright Product Protection, are specifically designed to offer both types of coverage from a single platform. Alternatively, you can use two separate, specialized apps - one for shipping (like Shipcheck) and another for product warranties (like My Product Registration).

3. What does "Free to install" mean?

"Free to install" means there is no upfront cost or monthly subscription fee to add the app to your store. However, these apps often have a usage-based cost structure. For example, they might take a small percentage of each protection plan sold or charge a fee per claim. This model is common for apps that partner with third-party insurers.

4. How do I manage claims with a self-funded insurance app?

With a self-funded app, you are the insurer. When a customer files a claim (usually through the app's portal), you review it against your policy terms. If approved, you fulfill the claim directly by sending a replacement order, issuing a refund, or providing store credit through your Shopify admin.

Conclusion

Integrating a shipping insurance app is a strategic move that enhances the customer experience, builds credibility, and creates a valuable new revenue channel. The best app for your store depends entirely on your business model - whether you prefer to manage your own risk for higher rewards with a self-funded app like Captain Shipping Protection or partner with a provider for ease of use with a solution like SureBright.

By carefully evaluating factors like the protection model, customization options, and claims process, you can select a tool that not only protects your customers' purchases but also strengthens your brand and boosts your bottom line.